The ransomware risk management calculus is changing for OT, ICS and critical infrastructure

2 months ago 36

Paralysis is the worst imaginable authorities for businesses to find themselves successful erstwhile faced with the threat, says Claroty's CPO.


ransomware alert

nevarpp, Getty Images/iStockphoto

Grant Geyer came aboard the concern cybersecurity institution Claroty successful April 2020 arsenic main merchandise serviceman amid the planetary pandemic and an detonation of ransomware attacks. In the archetypal fractional of 2020 with COVID-19 restrictions successful place, U.S.-based organizations unsocial saw a 109% emergence successful ransomware attacks, portion wide malware detections dropped 24% crossed the globe. 

Recent high-profile ransomware incidents, similar the May 2021 Colonial Pipeline attack, bespeak that not lone is ransomware a fiscal problem, but 1 that affects the exertion needed to support nine moving arsenic well. "We've reached a tipping constituent wherever events happening successful the cyber satellite tin interaction events successful the carnal one," Geyer said. 

Critical infrastructure, operational exertion (OT) and concern power systems (ICS) are becoming fashionable with attackers looking for brushed targets. In summation to being poorly prepared for the risks of being connected to the internet, the real-world consequences of a palmy onslaught connected manufacture and infrastructure springiness victims a superior inducement to pay.  

Needless to say, Geyer has a batch to accidental astir the menace ransomware poses to OT, ICS and captious infrastructure. Organizations hoping for an casual mode retired of the ransomware menace shouldn't get comfortable: There's a long, analyzable roadworthy up of the IT and OT worlds if Geyer is close successful his assessment, and he's not the lone 1 who thinks that way.

The emergence of the ransomware industry

Think of cybercriminals attacking companies with ransomware, and it's astir apt a azygous idiosyncratic successful a acheronian room, furiously penning malicious codification that comes to mind. Not so, Geyer said: Ransomware is fashionable and profitable capable that an full manufacture has sprung up astir its improvement and distribution.

"Less blase agents are taking action, multiplied based connected easiness of use, implementation, assistance table enactment and different factors making it arsenic casual arsenic pushing a fewer buttons," Geyer said. 

SEE: Security incidental effect policy (TechRepublic Premium)

Geyer isn't joking astir the beingness of assistance table enactment for some ransomware users and victims. One tiny Kentucky institution that fell prey to a ransomware onslaught successful 2020 was provided with a 1-800 number and told that the attacker was "here to help." The institution yet paid $150,000 to person its files released. 

As evidenced by caller ransomware attacks similar the Colonial Pipeline, and non-ransomware attacks similar the 1 connected the Oldsmar, Florida h2o attraction plan, attackers are becoming much aggressive. Western governments, Geyer said, person allowed them to enactment with comparative impunity. "They're stepping implicit the enactment without getting their hands slapped, truthful the enactment continues to move," Geyer said.

Ric Longenecker, CISO astatine Open Systems, warns that it's improbable the ransomware-as-a-service manufacture volition stay aimed astatine large targets. "These smaller targets whitethorn not warrant a monolithic payout, but there's little of a accidental of consequences oregon reprisals due to the fact that it is truly hard for authorities to diplomatically respond like-for-like to an onslaught that doesn't interaction captious industries oregon infrastructure." 

In short, there's a full manufacture based connected extorting companies, and it's not picky astir the target, arsenic agelong arsenic it pays out. And there's a bully likelihood it will, fixed the existent state of things. 

Why OT and ICS attacks are connected the rise

Digital transformation is happening successful astir each imaginable industry, and the OT, ICS and captious infrastructure broadside of things is conscionable the latest to embrace cloud-hosting for web and instrumentality management. That's bully for information logging, cost-saving and operational continuity, but atrocious for security.

"A laptop successful an IT situation is obsolete aft 3 to 4 years," Geyer said. "In OT, tech has a beingness of 15-20, adjacent 30 years. Those networks simply aren't built for the connectivity and information needs of today." 

Geyer notes that determination was a 74% summation successful vulnerabilities disclosed successful the vigor assemblage betwixt the 2nd fractional of 2018 and the 2nd fractional of 2020. "This highlights the information that the OT situation is rife with holes and inroads," Geyer said. 

Until integer translation deed the OT world, aerial gapping was the modular method of protecting concern and infrastructure networks. Without a transportation to the internet, there's nary hazard of attackers gaining access. John Dermody, erstwhile cybersecurity counsel astatine the NSC, DHS and DoD, agrees with Geyer's instrumentality connected the problems facing the OT world.

"As much exertion is integrated and added to concern systems, caller avenues for exploitation are created. Unlike IT strategy operators that person a ample assemblage to place vulnerabilities, and past of information being integrated into products, OT operators whitethorn person constricted penetration into the vulnerabilities lurking connected their system, conscionable waiting to beryllium exploited erstwhile they spot the airy of time (or the internet)," Dermody said.      

To marque matters worse, updating OT and ICS networks isn't arsenic casual arsenic updating IT, which isn't arsenic captious for operations. "Segmenting [or updating OT networks and hardware] would necessitate a attraction model which would intermission operations and production. It would necessitate truthful overmuch alteration that it whitethorn not beryllium practical," Geyer said. 

Old hardware and hesitancy to unopen down operations to code a theoretical aboriginal onslaught means that galore concern companies, municipalities and captious infrastructure are simply much consenting to wage the ransom. "When Baltimore faced a ransomware onslaught successful 2019 it decided not to wage ~$10,000 successful Bitcoin and ended up losing $18 cardinal successful revenue. With that equation successful mind, paying makes much sense," Geyer said. 

Prepare for penalties successful the look of inaction

"We request to displacement however boards of directors deliberation astir the fiscal consequences of not protecting their cyber environments," Geyer said, adding that portion question is happening to impact that change, it's going to instrumentality authorities enactment to yet marque it happen. "We request to make an situation that treats cyber hazard alongside different types of compliance risks and concern considerations." 

Geyer said that the Biden medication is mostly doing a bully occupation successful addressing the increasing ransomware menace to manufacture and infrastructure, citing the May enforcement order establishing aviator programs for Energy Star-like certifications for businesses that conscionable definite information standards. 

Dermody agrees that the scenery is changing: The TSA's pipeline information directive that arose successful the aftermath of the Colonial Pipeline hack are conscionable 1 example, helium said. "The government's appetite for imposing mandatory cybersecurity requirements has increased, and it is improbable that authorities regulatory efforts volition beryllium constricted to conscionable that captious infrastructure subsector. The authorities is not going to tolerate a script wherever determination are imaginable cascading effects." 

"Whether done caller regulatory requirements oregon done caller authorities connected the Hill, it is apt that much teeth are coming to authorities cybersecurity requirements," Dermody said.

Companies, similar the Kentucky 1 mentioned above, often usage 3rd parties and/or security companies to grip outgo of ransomware, which Splunk information advisor Ryan Kovar said could pb to companies sidestepping regulations. Dermody and Kovar some hold that paying ransoms fails to lick the problem; "Decrypting, adjacent erstwhile 100% successful, inactive takes days oregon weeks — adjacent months," Kovar said. 

Dermody believes that security companies volition request to person a accidental successful caller requirements arsenic well. "Insurance providers are actively looking for ways to mitigate risk, including done raising the outgo of policies and incentivizing prevention."  

How to hole for the aboriginal of ransomware hazard management

Infrastructure and concern companies person to look facts: Whether it's authorities regularisation oregon the aftermath of a ransomware attack, protecting OT and ICS networks is simply a precedence now.

Preventing phishing attacks, grooming users to admit threats, filtering emails, mounting due firewall rules, segmenting networks (when possible), and different cybersecurity champion practices are lone 1 portion of protecting analyzable OT networks. 

SEE: How to negociate passwords: Best practices and information tips (free PDF) (TechRepublic)

Don't presume that champion practices see endpoint detection and effect (EDR) oregon endpoint extortion level (EPP) software. "We're seeing an uptick successful attacks connected captious infrastructure due to the fact that attacks are working. Until we admit that EDR and EPP are going to miss attacks, we volition proceed to beryllium subjected to much malware and ransomware," said Illumio's VP of merchandise management, Matt Glenn. Glenn besides believes that bully IT infrastructure is portion of bully OT infrastructure, and that shoring up 1 involves shoring up the other. 

Quoting Louis Pasteur, Geyer makes the remainder of the process beauteous cut-and dry: "Fortune favors the prepared mind." 

The "three lines of defense" exemplary of cybersecurity fashionable successful IT environments is perfectly suited to adaptation successful OT and ICS, Geyer said. For those unfamiliar with the model, it puts owners and managers of hazard (IT, cybersec teams, etc.) astatine the archetypal line. Second comes hazard and compliance groups that oversee and show first-line teams. Last comes interior audits, and it's present wherever minds get prepared.  

Get leaders unneurotic astir a table, Geyer recommends, and tally low-cost tabletop exercises wherever everyone with a involvement successful a information incidental gets to exemplary their response. "Real-time exercises similar these amusement however determination makers think, however the process works, and however the enactment arsenic a full volition respond," helium said.

Exercises similar these are besides a cardinal mode of creating visibility connected networks. Sachin Shah, CTO of OT and Armis, uses protecting a location against burglary to explicate this important measurement successful web enumeration: "[I would] locomotion astir the location and cheque to spot if each my windows and doors are closed, locked oregon perchance broken. Once I person done that, astatine slightest I cognize what my hazard is. I mightiness request to instal amended locks oregon immoderate much floodlights, but I cognize wherever I stand." 

It's besides important, Geyer said, for organizations to cognize wherever their method safeguards should beryllium focused. "Ransomware goes aft Windows systems, truthful cognize wherever they are successful your situation and however they are vulnerable, past instrumentality steps to remediate the hazard with updates and information patches. 

Organizations that instrumentality these steps with a mindset toward growth, learning and betterment volition yet person "a well-informed knowing of their vulnerabilities, including a realistic knowing that radical are going to marque mistakes," said Dermody. "It's important to understand, and sermon successful advance, however you would respond successful specified a crisis.  When servers are locking up astir you is not erstwhile you should beryllium deciding for the archetypal clip whether you are good with paying a ransom," helium said. 

OT, ICS and captious infrastructure networks tin beryllium huge, and it's casual for radical to beryllium paralyzed into inaction, Geyer said. Paralysis is the worst imaginable authorities for businesses to find themselves successful erstwhile faced with ransomware. 

Whether it happens present oregon successful the adjacent respective years, the ransomware hazard absorption calculus is changing. While it whitethorn beryllium much outgo effectual to pay a ransom successful 2021, the onus volition soon beryllium connected concern leaders and boards to forestall a ransomware onslaught from ever happening. Organizations that privation to hole for the aboriginal would bash good to woody with the headaches of prevention earlier betterment becomes an adjacent larger burden. 

Cybersecurity Insider Newsletter

Strengthen your organization's IT information defenses by keeping abreast of the latest cybersecurity news, solutions, and champion practices. Delivered Tuesdays and Thursdays

Sign up today

Also spot

Read Entire Article